Home

Home

Profile

Profile

Activities

Activities

Contact

Contact

 
 
 

Facts Speak For Thenselves
Introduction
Failure Of Governing Glass
Data Collection
Objectivity In Observation And Analysis
Fifty Eight Pilgrims Roasted Alive
Staff Of Railway Station Godhra
Passengers Travelling In Sabarmati Express
Witness To Later Part Of Incident
Facts That Need Verifications
Administrative Response
Camps
Role Of Media
Conclusions
Recommendations Alternate Plan Of
  Thought And Action

DATA COLLECTION

VISITS INTERACTION AND DOCUMENTS

The team reached Ahmedabad on 02.04.02 in the morning by train and visited three affected areas, and some of the relief camps. At all the places team members interacted with the members of the public freely without intervention of any officials, government or otherwise.

On 03.04.02 the team went to Godhra and five delegations from both communities and also of mixed composition presented their views and facts to the team. The team then went to the Godhra Railway Station and interviewed the officials and some other witnesses of the burning of the S-6 Coach of the Sabarmati Express in the morning of 27.02.02. The site where the train was initially stopped and stoned was also visited. The team also minutely observed the burnt S-6 coach. The officials of the Fire Brigade who were involved in the fire fighting on the morning of 27.02.02 were also interviewed. The localities adjacent to the railway station along with the sites where demolition of structures illegally erected was carried out on 27.02.02 during the curfew hours were also visited. The team also visited a Girl High School at Godhara where Muslims from rural hinterland had migrated for safety.

In the evening the team had a meeting with the District Collector, Godhra along with other officials. The District Collector made a presentation of the actions that the district administration had taken after the incident near the railway station. Information was also provided in response to the questions raised by the members of the team. Prime Minister was to reach Godhra the next day and the team left for Vadodara late at night, as it did not want to be an obstacle in the arrangements being made for his visit.

RELIEF CAMPS OF HINDUS AND MUSLIMS

On 04.04.02 the team was in Vadodara where it visited five relief camps of both the communities and seven areas, which were the scenes of arson, fire and violence during the last month. Team also exposed itself to ground situations by visiting some sensitive areas where either:

a.                  two communities lived face to face with each other in different localities.

b.                  a small number of families of one community lived in neighborhood and surrounded by a large number of the families of the other community.

c.                  two communities lived in the same locality, both in significant numbers with houses of both communities randomly distributed.

The team also visited some of the areas, which have been evacuated by the residents because they were attacked or they apprehended an attack. To have the exposure to the realities the team also visited some areas where curfew was imposed. Permission to visit such areas was taken from the appropriate authorities.

In the afternoon the Commissioner Police, Vadodra and District Collector Vadodra met the team along with other officials. The team members were updated with the information regarding the management of situation till that day. The officials also answered the queries of the team.

At 5.00 pm the team met with the representatives of various media organizations, both print and electronic media. About thirty media persons were present and an informative interaction took place. The team had taken a conscious decision not to have a press conference, as it did not want to express unprocessed, half-baked and impressionistic opinions.

MEETING THE GOVERNOR & THE CHIEF MINISTER

In the evening thirteen (13) delegations consisting of 121 citizens met the team and presented their viewpoints and information. The delegations included not only the members of both the communities but ranged from the Association of Hoteliers to a group of adivasis to affected Muslim and Hindu women.

On 05.04.02 the team once again visited the affected areas to see the change in the ground situation in two days after the team has visited on 02.04.02. Here once again the team spoke to common persons at the affected sites. In the afternoon the team had an interactive meeting with Shri Narender Modi, Chief Minister, Gujarat. After meeting the Chief Minister, the team met the Police Commissioner, Ahmedabad. He gave some data about the preventive arrests (3046), booked (1807), FIRs lodged (636) killed (267 including 58 in police firing) and rounds fired by police (2842). In the afternoon seven delegations five from Ahmedabad and two representing state level organizations apprised the team of their version of the incidents, perceptions and possible remedial measures. Total number of citizens, both Muslims and Hindus, present in these meetings was 91. During and after dinner some important persons of the minority community met the team members personally and provided useful information. This included a retired judge of the High Court belonging to the Muslim community. His house had been burnt a few days ago. In the morning of 06.04.02 team members went out individually to interact informally with common men to feel the pulse of the people. At noon the team went to Raj Bhawan to meet Shri Sunder Singh Bhandari, Governor, Gujarat where a very useful interaction took place.

 
 

Email This Page

  Print This Page